Sunday, 9 August 2015

Why YES lost: a reply to Gerry Hassan's claims in the Daily Record

Gerry Hassan writes:-
  • A second Scots indyref is likely but not inevitable. It will only happen when it is winnable, Yes is in a significant lead, and importantly, detailed work has been done to improve and make more credible than last time the indy offer. My Sunday column.(Gerry Hassan on a second independence referendum - 'A new vote on an independent Scotland must be economically honest - not based on fantasy oil prices writes GERRY HASSAN.')

  • Nick Durie This is dishonest, and echoes the Unionist crowing with hindsight. The SNP's projected oil revenues relied on a price that was midway between the OBR projection and the Department for Energy and Climate Change projection. The Daily Record might lap up such Unionist sophistry but the facts say something different.

  • Gerry Hassan Good to know you are thinking Nick; 'Unionist crowing' to point out as someone who voted Yes the limits of SNP indy offer and the complete lack of any post-indyref reappraisal. Yes lost and deserved to lose: welcome to reality.


  • Nick Durie You didn't address my point.
    • Nick Durie You claim that oil projections were a fantasy. Why were they less than those issued by the UK Department for Energy and Climate Change?

  • Nick Durie The fact of the matter is that oil price projections were based on market trends and market fundamentals, and they did not anticipate that Saudi Arabia would flood the energy market to destabilise Russia and collapse US fracking. This was not something the British Government anticipated either, and claiming some kind of post facto foreknowledge while adopting an "It was rubbish" Unionist frame is not the same thing as providing a credible critque. Neither a Scottish currency, nor attempted accession to the Euro is without problems; furthermore neither of those two options does anything to reassure those worried that their savings and investments, denominated in Sterling, would be secure. That was afterall the whole point of the "You're not getting the Pound" frame - to terrorise that cohort that held savings and investments denominated in Sterling. Simply saying 'we won't have Sterling anymore' does not resolve or de-weaponise that attack line; it actually makes it stronger. People were not worried about the future of Sterling in Scotland because of some haivers about central banks. They were worried about their savings and investments.
  • Gerry Hassan Everything about the economics of the indyref offer was a fantasy: oil price, economic projections, currency, Treasury/Bank of England straightjacket. And all only made sense in light of SNP leadership thinking they would lose and instead engage in a vote maximalisation strategy. Then late on they convinced themselves they could win.
    • Nick Durie This is a media bubble argument which owes more to the self-congratulatory discourse of the Unionist commentariat than it does to any extant evidence. The currency strategy was determined by a council of economists, not politicians. The SNP chose simply to follow it; whether their political calculus determined it was good to follow it or not, that strategy was, as you know, written by some very globally notable economists. The oil price was essentially a UK government and Scottish government consensus. The shared central bank is a threat, a gun to the head of Whitehall, and a determination to give the spivs a golden bridge, rather than collapse the London banking centre by immediately denominating Scottish energy in another currency. To claim otherwise to any of that is to fail to engage with the evidence.
  • Nick Durie "Yes lost and deserved to lose: welcome to reality."

    This assumes that the YES offer was why YES lost. I don't think that's particularly materialist. In many ways YES did deserve to lose, but I would argue it lost because the formal YES and SNP camp
    aign concentrated on public relations and fought a very good election campaign, but the depth of citizen engagement with the issue left that approach looking top down and shallow. Citizens were interrogating the question with a zealous seriousness that is not analogous to an electoral cycle contest. The wider mass movement of the YES campaign came to understand that, and had to make up for the shortcomings of the offical and largely corporate style campaign. Consider how much more seriously the Wee Blue Book took the reader than the official YES literature, Your Future, which notionally filled the same role. The latter was put together by a PR company. The former was written in a referenced academic style where the reader could go and check the footnotes. Yet YES HQ reacted to these on the ground efforts with umbrage, and often deliberately sabotaged the logistics of the on the gound campaign, purely to maintain the PR voice of the campaign 


    [In one notorious particular instance of this YES' point man for 'organising' of the YES movement, Ross Greer, got into a fight of his choosing with a local YES campaign group because they were distributing leaflets advertising Scotland's most popular, and pro-independence, political news website Wings Over Scotland; YES HQ continued to oppose the distribution of the Wee Blue Book, also produced by Wings Over Scotland, despite activists finding both that this was the single most effective written introduction to the arguments for independence, and the widespread desire of local YES groups to get more serious and comprehensive literature to the switherin voters because of the feedback they had been getting from these voters.  It appeared that YES HQ ignored that feedback, because little was done to distribute non-PR based publications in this kind of format. 

    The pointless, and often apparently petulent, self-sabotaging of the actual YES movement by Ross Greer and others at YES HQ caused serious rifts within the campaign and damaged the credibility of the campaign centre among those it sought, wholly inexpertly, to direct.  We now know from Greer that this petulence from the centre went further, and that, without any accountability, disciplinary procedure or published code of conduct, Ross Greer and Jonathan Mackie operated personal blacklists of campaigners they personally didn't like; we will perhaps never know the extent of this practice, but it typifies the strained relationship between the failing campaign centre and the more successful huge movement that had built up often in despite of it.]. 


    To some extent the upbeat smugness of the PR campaign did however act as a late stage force multiplier on the late stage undecideds, but by this point the official campaign had already burnt many bridges with its actual on the ground logistics. It was the absence of these logistics that prevented YES from mobilising its own base, and saw many YES activists late on in the campaign do largely frivolous things. The infrastructure of the official campaign prattled on and castigated those people, but they were not plugged in to their official campaign precisely because it had been so incompetent at building and directing a peoples movement*, and had therefore totally lost the respect and capacity to mobilise its own potential logistics, nor did it have the vision to do so. This was why YES lost by 180,000 votes. It had little or nothing to do with the actual offer.

    *[At no point did the YES HQ employ or seek the advice of professional trade union or community organisers with experience of building mass movements; there were a number of such people involved in the grassroots of the YES campaign, many of them with decades of experience in trade union organising drives, or community coalition building.  Their skills were never called upon or utilised in any kind of systematic way.  For those who have seen the effects of a trade union or community organising drive with a staff led organising component, this seems a serious ommission, and perhaps explains why following campaign "launch" events drawing in hundreds of potential leaders. in major towns and cities, often nothing happened as a followup to engage with this base for 12 months or more.  The entire approach to the logistics of engagement played a less important role for Greer and others notionally tasked with organising the logistics, than the question of brand maintenance and PR, which in the end proved less significant to the result than the number of one to one conversations the actual movement was having, independent of any direction or cajoling from the YES centre, with undecided voters.]

Wednesday, 1 July 2015

Scottish Greens: From 'monetary' haivers to 'too wee, too poor, too stupid'

Green noteable Ross Greer responding to serious questions raised after Caroline Lucas MP voted
against Home Rule after "doing best to reflect views of colleagues in @scotgp @patrickharvie"

Today was the day that the Scottish Green Party policing of opposing Home Rule, and all that this fiscal conservatism implies in terms of enforcing austerity, came to the proper attention of the democracy movement.  This follows a vote earlier in the week in the House of Commons where Green MP Caroline Lucas voted with the Tories to defeat an SNP motion calling for the phased introduction of full taxation powers, which would have given Scotland Home Rule.

Months previously Scottish Green Party Convenor Patrick Harvie MSP had maundered in the National and for Commonspace on why the Greens (probably) opposed "Full Fiscal Autonomy."  However the use of the jargon and his non-committal 'this needs more work' style of delivery meant most activists and democracy supporters eyes glazed over before they could come to understand the implications of this apparently technical statement.

The Greens initial supposed point was that devolving control over taxation to Holyrood would leave us hostage to whatever the Bank of England decided to do about our currency and interest rates.  They made some rather curious points about an inability to borrow which need teasing out because they are utter haivers.

Giving Scotland full control over taxation would not, in and of itself, allow Scotland to borrow money.  The UK government issues debt by selling government bonds it creates which are called "gilts" (the UK has a funny special word for government bonds, which are basically government IOUs - which can themselves be bought and sold, or speculated on - because the UK is a fousty old empire and likes to have stupid words of its own for something every country does; they are no different from any other government bonds).  There are no proposals on the table or recently defeated proposals off the table to be able to allow Scotland to issue these "gilts" in its own name.

That *doesn't quite* mean Scotland can't borrow money tho.  The new Forth Brig has been financed by money from the "Scottish Futures Trust" (SFT), which is basically a series of loan deals between the Scottish government and individual private sector lenders, on negotiated terms.  These aren't government bonds tho, because they are specific to the projects, or bound by individual contractual arrangements, whereas bonds are a much more universal and therefore more 'liquid' asset.  The Scottish Government has been trying to create its own system of regular debt financing and bring these debts into a more regularised system of debt and interest along the lines of bonds markets.  That's what the whole SFT thing is about, and why it's not just a series of private finance deals.  But here is the rub, unless there is enough debt issued on behalf of the government, it is not possible for the government to treat this as a sustainable market for government finance in the way that UK gilts, or the more pedestrian (and less up itself) named US Treasury bonds are.  There needs to be enough IOUs floating around for international investors to care about or trade in them, and for a standardised rate of interest to emerge on what would then be effectively real Scottish Government bonds to emerge.  I.e. we do not need to access Westminster's gilt markets to issue government bonds on behalf of the Holyrood government, and do real government borrowing; it is simply a question of scale.  Roughly around £10billion needs to be issued in debts before there would be a secure market for Scottish government borrowing.  It wouldn't necessarily have the same rate of interest as UK government borrowing, but it would have *a* regular rate of interest, and it would allow us to *END AUSTERITY.*

The problem at the moment is that the Scottish Government's budget sits at about £30billion.  There is no collateral for the Scottish Government to issue that amount of debt.  However under Home Rule this position is reversed.  If we are able to access the money raised in Scotland, and spend it in Scotland (or on the 'shared services'/tribute payments towards our glorious Union), we would be able to establish a secure Scottish bonds market, and therefore be able to *completely end austerity*, within the Union.  The Scottish Green perspective that this is risky within a currency union and so forth omits that at the present moment our economy and society *is being destroyed* by Westminster's austerity programme.  The Greens position then starts to seem like an awfully theoretical splitting of hairs when action is needed now.  In effect voting against Home Rule amounts to voting for continuing austerity.  How is this preferable?  Any risk incurred through having a shared currency with Westminster is also a risk for the Whitehall state, and that also has the benefit of encouraging the British state to start to see Scotland as better off independent anyway.  This twiddling of thumbs while the children of benefit claimants starve was enough to send a snell scunner through the movement by itself, however in defending their dippit policy the Greens's leadership have been rather more revealing about their attitudes towards Scotland than perhaps they at first realise.

Cos obviously if we controlled our own taxes, and had the ability to
borrow they'd have to call in the IMF, right?  Is Patrick Harvie's
twitter account now being run by Peter Jones from the Scotsman?

When Greens like Ross Greer start to talk about *PHASED* tax devolution to Holyrood (which has all these advantages I've spelt out) as 'enforcing austerity' they start to sound very much like Labour, and one careerist Greer becomes another careerist Dugdale merging into a monotone cacophony of self-doubting cringing verbiage, straining to douse any last hope beneath a blah blah of identikit 'realism.' 

And yet the Greens are asking for SNP members to lend them their second vote in the forthcoming Holyrood elections on a constitutional change ticket?  Perhaps 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' is not quite the amazing chat up line it's cracked up to be?  Can someone tell the leader.  Under pressure to defend his party's vacuous policy of enforcing Tory spending at Holyrood to avoid 'risk,' Patrick Harvie let the mask slip. 

There is no doubt the many thousands of new members who joined the Greens in the aftermath of the referendum did so because the Greens were in favour of independence and autonomy for Scotland.  Perhaps it is time they started to rein in a leadership that seems on the face of it to have been exposed as preferring Unionist managerialism to real autonomy and broken down into a paroxysm of cringing at Scotland's economy.  The issues at stake - the lives of our poorest citizens - are too important to allow the Greens' feart managerialist leadership to allow our movement to fracture into self-defeating Scotch cringe and Unionism Lite posturing.  It is time they were called out for opposing democracy and autonomy by their own members.  Holyrood needs Home Rule, and we need to end austerity.  Trying to separate these immediate demands from the democracy struggle can only weaken our movement.

Tuesday, 17 March 2015

I have become the "unacceptable face" of Scottish nationalism

I have just had the bizarre and unexpected experience of becoming the unacceptable face of "Scottish nationalism."

If you have united Ross Greer and Stuart Campbell in condemnation of you it is worth taking a step back.

I am a little confused that journos from the mighty Daily Record consider my words so noteworthy they are worthy of retweeting, but for the record what I wrote was the following. (see right)

I am sorry if my intemperate tone has caused offence to the wrong parties.  Genuinely.  I am.  My intent was to communicate the following points.

1. The journalist Aidan Kerr was once considered a local stalwart of the forces of progressive social change, and democracy for Scotland.  He was elected leader of a student nationalist association.

2. As as insider Kerr developed a "map" - a picture of the social relationships, and the stories, anecdotes and power relationships between individuals within the democracy movement.

3. Kerr abandonned his apparently heartfelt beliefs when he became a professional journalist, and began writing scurrilous articles in support of the British establishment, for money.

4. This insider information, coupled with his willingness to surrender his principles for money has made Kerr dangerous.  The ultimate validation of this is the extent to which the Depute Editor for the Record is working his socks off to hype Kerr's output on social media.  People in the democracy movement should beware of such individuals, as they maintain links and sources of information, but they have no principles and are ultimately interested in money first and foremost.

This was the extent of my point.  Had I expressed it less trenchantly, or in the post modern 'ironic' way, I doubt very much the noble Aidan Kerr would be soliciting the views of the Green candidate for East Dunbartonshire.

Let me explain why I reacted so hostilely to Kerr's latest (now frontpage) attempts to troll for the Daily Record.

1. During the course of canvassing I have met a great many people who - as a result of the system of benefit sanctions Kerr, now a Unionist, upholds - could not feed their children.  In one discussion in Possil I met a woman with three kids who had not eaten in days, who was intent on voting NO, because in her eyes Scotland was worth nothing.  She voted YES, after I had spoken to her.  Her understanding of which parliament controlled which powers and who was enacting which policy was poor.  She had been reading the Unionist red top newspapers that Kerr now plies his trade for.  The same Unionism had handed down to her a benefit sanction of three months with no money, the cause of which she still did not know or understand.  Kerr has joined in this system of misinformation, exclusively for the money, against his previous principles.  Meantime in the month of August 2014 my residents association held a crisis meeting because over 600 people in my local area had relied on food parcels between April and May.  By October that number was up to 1000.  My community voted YES overwhelmingly, but people like Kerr changed their allegiance when the money flowed the right way.

I know how I feel about this.  It makes me intemperate and angry.  I refuse to apologise about being angry about such naked injustice, or towards those who can react dispassionately towards such evil and vindictive things, or ignore the causes of them, when Scotland's second largest red top flashes pound notes.

2. People like Kerr have deep roots, which they will use as contacts.  Kerr has his defenders in the movement, who will defend him every bit as vociferously as David Clegg.  Clegg now considers Kerr's attack pieces frontpage news.  Clegg's paper is one of the primary institutions upholding food poverty, reaction, and two faced concern for poverty.  Lots of pathos, with an exhortation to vote for monetarism.  Call me an extremist every bit as much as you like, but I personally consider that seedy in the extreme.

3. Which is worse - being an intemporate mouth on social media with an audience of a few hundred fellow travellers, or writing a scurrilous piece of divisive and disingenuous claptrap which enters the households of 300,000 Scots and tells them to know their place?

4. Ross Greer and Stuart Campbell united on the same side - can't be doing half bad, eh. ;p

So mea culpa, and I'm sorry for using the wrong tone, and being very shouty.  I am human and stupid.  But that doesn't mean we should be taken for fools.

Monday, 16 February 2015

The Serpent's Egg and the Brown Plague

“No one understands better than the people of this land how a severely depressed economy, combined with a ritual national humiliation and unending hopelessness, can hatch the serpent’s egg within its society. When I return home tonight, I will find a country where the third-largest party is not a neo-nazi party, but a nazi party.” -- Yanis Varoufakis

All Scottish Europeans need to understand that we live within a wider context than purely our relations within England's empire.

Europe is now on the brink.  This is an epochal time.  States and empires may fall or change hands, and coups and revolutions have already taken places as a result of the ongoing economic crisis, and the misery our corrupt liberal rulers have inflicted with austerity.

Greece' third largest political party, the Nazi "Golden Dawn".
Detailing the insignia of new government militas in the Ukraine,
who deliberately evoke the iconography of Ukrainian Nazis during
World War 2. The US installed Ukrainian coup regime is a mixture
of Nazis and billionaire gangsters and their henchmen. It is currently
carpet bombing and shelling housing schemes, and running paramilitary
death squads in the East of the state for the crime of opposing the coup,
and favouring democratic elections to decide the country's future.
 "You cannot promote nazism in one country and suppose that it will stay within that country’s borders. The wave of Nazism spreads to all, overstepping boundaries. That’s the reason they called Nazism “The Brown Plague.” Nazism must be stopped at the distant approaches, lest it arrive in your house. [...] Should anyone suppose that one can simply ignore Ukrainian fascism, and pay no attention to it, he is utterly in error. The nature of Nazism is such that it takes being ignored as encouragement, even as an acknowledgement of its strength. Nazism is never local; it can only root, and grow. Therefore the only way with Nazism is an active bitter struggle against it." - Open letter to Angela Merkel from veterans of Stalingrad.
 
In England, and Wales, there is a return to 'David Stirling style' end of empire chauvinist nostalgia mixed with a bit of Enoch Powell style imperial racism, in the service of some forces in the City of London.

In Scotland the spectre of Metternich, while currently a distant discordant and unpopular voice, is gathering pace, with certain Unionists rallying against "appeasement."  Currently precocious, a rout of the Scottish Government would provide the conditions necessary for just such an approach.  Putting democracy back in its box in Scotland (when Unionists discuss 'winning the peace,' that is of course what they mean) would require a crackdown and a linked demoralisation of the democracy movement.  There are those who consider this political possibility feverish hyperbole, citing the UK as a liberal democracy where freedom of thought, speech and action are cherished norms.  They would do well to observe the practices of the UK when it faces existential threat, and have a cursory swatch of the past 50 years of history in these islands.  The UK is perfectly capable of running death squads, interning dissidents, or executing those it considers a threat to security.  What has been done before, in our lifetimes, in the hinterland of the state we live in, can be done again.

It's always helpful in assessing political "possibles" to find out if there are any advocates of a particular approach.  It turns out ending "appeasement" for the Jocks is actually quite popular with the grassroots of Unionism and the right of the Whitehall regime.  No appeasement, and an iron fist state is now a popular message among the enemies of political and economic democracy in these islands.  It is not part of any centrist liberal party's official programme, but UKIP advocate such an approach, and along with the reactionaries of the DUP, they may yet be in government before the next Holyrood election.

We as a continent face a choice.  We can embrace the Green New Deal, and win greater economic democracy, or we can push regimes into reaction and outright fascism, by forcing their citizens into penury and desperate hopelessness.

There are those who argue that the proposals of Sinn Fein, the SNP, Syriza, Podemos, Plaid Cymru, the English Greens and other parties who would kill austerity are insufficiently radical, do not address fundamentals and so on.  There is no doubt that they are often right, or at least partially correct in their specific concerns.  There is no doubt too that space created by discrediting these parties of a reformed Europe would allow a yet more radical challenger, a less centrist voice, to emerge and articulate these demands.  Again this is true.  But political space in an era of revolution (no less a reactionary than Iain Duncan Smith terms our times such), where the centre of politics is collapsing due to the generalised misery it is enforcing, is also a crisis for the left.  History has shown that where the left fails to capture the centre in times such as these, the Brown Plague is very happy to fill that void.  A few wrong steps here and there, a miscalculation, a defeat in the negotiations for Syriza, or a demoralisation of the democracy movement and the SNP, and it could be Metternich or a jackboot. 

Several countries in Europe (the Ukraine and Italy) have already fallen to foreign backed dictatorship.  Recent polling in West Germany is unlikely to weaken the resolve of Germany's Tories to see Southern and peripheral Europe burn, and, amidst the depression caused by following the failed economic strategies of the early 1930s with predictable conclusions, many centrist governments teetering on the brink in the austerity consensus are egging on the smashing of Greece out of pathetic sectional interest.

A generalised defeat for the forces of progressive change in Europe, here in Scotland with the SNP, and abroad in Ireland, Greece, and Spain, may prove all the succour that the Serpent's Egg, now hatched and napalming housing schemes in the East of Europe, needs in order to hatch in Europe's South and North West.

Tuesday, 23 December 2014

A response to Sandy Wilkie in the National

Sandy Wilkie sent a letter to the National yesterday in which he purported to be taking an ecumenical tone, talking about #OneScotland.  In the same letter however Wilkie lets the mask slip;

"Perhaps [the First Minister] has enough on her plate trying to assimilate the 45ers whose strong views were unleashed by her predecessor; unleashed without any thought as to the genie being let out of that particular bottle?"

Who are these dread democrats?  Hatred and fear of popular politics is most notably associated with the right, and indeed is the foundational conerstone of conservative politics.  If Wilkie is the "left leaning idealist who believes in a federal UK solution" he confesses himself to be one would think this cohort of Scots who want democracy instead of remote Whitehall rule are not very far from Wilkie's position?  If not, why not?  The repeated wild animal metaphors the young Labour activist uses rather give the game away. 

I am not remotely an idealist, but as an internationalist and a socialist, I could only vote YES, campaign for YES, and repudiate the reactionary British state - one of the most venal and imperialistic polities ever created.  My response to the referendum result was to stick an A2 YES poster in the window, because of what this rebellion represents - a left wing rejection of imperialism, chauvinism, backwardness and Tory reaction.  The formal technical arrangements by which Scots get to opt out of the far right consensus that characterises the three Tory parties at Westminster is far less consequential to me than simply that we do, and at the very earliest opportunity, taking control of our natural resources to establish some form of social democratic commonwealth.

Nevertheless the federalist who wants to 'leash' fellow Scottish democrats goes on to qualify his support for "federalism" but invoking the Smith Commission and the need he sees not to suggest it does not go far enough.  This is a body designed to deliver a rehashed Calman Commission, and a settlement so far from Home Rule (defined as the same as Dominion Status within the British Empire) and federalism as to be palpably ridiculous.  This prompts questions about how deep his ostensible federalism runs, because the Smith Commission is a mandate for continued unitary British state and the absolute sovereignty of Whitehall in fiscal and social security affairs, which brings us to his next point. He claims we need to be "taking active responsibility for making things better," yet he refuses to trouble himself with taking responsibility for the contradictions of his position.

For many of us the democracy rebellion - for that's what it remains - is not an academic exercise, as it appears it is for our "federalist" who somehow mananged to reconcile his beliefs with working a 22 hour shift for the campaign against democracy on polling day.  In communities blighted by Whitehall rule this rebellion *remains* a zero sum game.  In August of this year my residents association held an emergency local meeting in response to the escalating humanitarian crisis in our community.  Large numbers of us aren't eating.  The local foodbank was set up following poverty stricken residents needing to steal food from the big Tesco to survive.  At the time of the August meeting we had data to show that during May 623 people around our estate had to rely on food parcels to eat.  Over 60% of our community went on to vote YES.  One month after the right's pyhrric victory in October 623 had become over 1000 relying on food parcels to eat.  This horror continues to escalate.  When will Wilkie, the man who hails from the party which caused this crisis, take some responsibility?

Perhaps because our "federalist" qualifies his left wing credentials by saying he's an "idealist" we maybe need to inject some empiricism.  The British state is starving poor Scots because of conditionality in the benefits system, introduced by James Purnell in 2009 under the last UK Labour government, who was advised by one Blair McDougall at the time.  The system of sanctions and work capability assessments introduced by McDougall and Purnell were found by the SCVO to be not just the primary cause of food poverty but (together with Westminster's labour market regulation: another thing we don't get to 'take responsibility for') the almost exclusive cause of it.  Currently DWP targets state that 5% of all welfare recipients must be sanctioned every two weeks, regardless of circumstance, so the 'conditionality' merely matches the target, as was always intended.  This conditionality (the sanctions regime) is *designed* to starve people in communities like mine, with the only conceiveable aim being to 'discipline' the labour market.  This labour market discipline (and the low wage economy it precipitates) is why there is cross party consensus among the Tory parties of power at Westminster, because this is the point of ideological unity.  This is what the NO campaign was about enforcing in Scotland, so our 'left-leaning federalist' would absolutely *have* to be an idealist to fail to interface with this.  Let me spell it out to Wilkie because he seems too interested in his own idealism to understand the reason we remain in rebellion: the British state is currently starving 2% of Scots as an act of *cross party consensus,* which will be exacerbated by whoever wins the next UK election; there is only one way in which this will not be the case.

That is if the Red Tories - let's call the centre right opposition what they objectively are - are condemned to electoral irrelevance in Scotland and Scots can force the Red Tory Chancellor in waiting to cancel his planned £86billion of cuts, circumscribe the vile right wing extremist Rachel Reeves, and thereby restore food to the table of the 2% of Scots Wilkie has worked 22 hour shifts to immiserate.  NO activists like Wilkie continue to refuse to take responsibility for the misery their selfish right wing actions have caused.  We can all accept when folk mea culpa and admit they got it wrong, and that they now wish to join the fight for democracy.  However the idea that right wing activists should get to lecture us about solidarity and communitarian ethics when their arguments consist of astroturfing, victim blaiming, characterising those whom they claim to share so much with rhetorically as wild animals, British nationalist Schmalz and disingenuous confessions of left wing faith is a vile travesty.  Objectively these British nationalist activists stand for remote far right rule that is causing an escalating humanitarian crisis.  This is a zero sum game Mr Wilkie, and if you want to have any credibibility at all with democrats and not just with privately educated Red Tory councillors it's about time you took some some responsibility and joined us in the fight to end Labour's policy of promoting and escalating starvation in working class communities.

Monday, 15 December 2014

Why a vote for Labour in Scotland is a vote for a colonial relationship and reaction

1. Scotland is a colony.  The Anglo-Scottish Union is a colonial relationship.

2. The Labour Party is the strongest source of fealty to the Union in Scotland.

3. The Labour Party in Scotland is the leading force for reaction. 



1.)



This is how wikipedia defines a colony.  Get sniffy about the source if you like, but its definition seems pretty accurate.
"In politics and history, a colony is a territory under the immediate political control of a state, distinct from the home territory of the sovereign.[...]Unlike a puppet state or satellite state, a colony has no independent international representation, and its top-level administration is under direct control of the metropolitan state."
Miriam Webster has: "an area that is controlled by or belongs to a country and is usually far away from it."

The reason for maintaining a colony is pretty simple: resource extraction, and to project military force.  It is easier to deploy troops in a territory that is under your jurisdiction than it is to attempt landings or invasions in places which are not.

For the first half of the Union, the '45 clampdown excepted, Scotland was in a state of "semi-independence."  It was not a colony, but the result of a ruling class compact where Scotland was officially annexed on terms.  It was to borrow a fairly exact metaphor a satrapy.

"the Achaemenian Empire[...] established 20 satrapies with their annual tribute. As the head of the administration of his province, the satrap collected taxes and was the supreme judicial authority; he was responsible for internal security and raised and maintained an army. [...] the satraps often enjoyed virtual independence."

A Satrap holds court in S. Afghanistan.  Satrapies enjoyed semi-independence, within an empire.
This semi-independence was characterised by local control and exercise of power.  The institutions involved were the Kirk, and the justiciary (which was in the pocket of the landowning classes and, aware of their own illegitimacy and their fragile position of dual power, was by turns cautious and liberal and reactionary and revanchist).  The Kirk controlled health, education (parish and higher education), welfare, civil law, fines and levies, and even had control over migration.  Labour market regulation, law making, taxation and civil defence were in the hands of the lairds.  Westminster controlled wars and foreign colonies, and so long as the Jocks didn't cause too many problems, who were they to trouble themselves with the administration of Scotland.  Besides which colonies were providing much of the resource extraction.

This period of satrapy status ended when the British state grew in Scotland.  After this point Scotland became more or less a colony in the traditional sense, and ceased to be a satrapy.  It first became a nascent satrapy again in 2007.

The Disruption Assembly of 1843: one of the key moments when Scottish dual power which emerged in 1560 died.
The mechanism for the British state's growth and Scotland's long interregnum was the smashing of the Kirk, and the establishment of ministerial control over Scotland from London.  In 1846 the British state started to build free schools, in competition with parish schools, before long it would annexe the welfare system and health and social care; the landed classes had already undermined the Kirk's migration controls, and were busily undermining Kirk sessions wherever they could.  The context for these moves was the British state's attacks on the power of the Kirk, in which the landowning classes of Scotland had acted with British government support to insist and rule in favour of land owning patronage in the Kirk, in appointing ministers, in opposition to a parish membership ballot.  Before this attack on the Kirk the civil adminstration of much of Scotland by the Kirk meant it had been handled in a different way and according to different priorities.  The Kirk could be a very ideologically intolerant place, but its radical democracy would make Switzerland look centralised.  This attack, faced down by the General Assembly, but later enforced by the Court of Session led to a massive split in the Kirk, known as the Disruption of 1843.  This blew a hole in the dual power of the people against our rulers, and they seized their moment to 'go British' by having a London minister put directly in charge of running the various public services they colluded in having the British state annexe from Scotland.  By 1885, following decades of Scottish elite agitation, there was a secretary of state in charge of running all of the things from an office in London.


This is also about where the former civil servant John Jappy's evidence acts to corroborate the central assumption that Scotland was a satrapy, which became a colony under Scottish ruling class expediancy and British centralising pressure:- 

[That this process should be completed towards the end of the 19th century, during the New Imperialism when Britain was getting a bit skint and plumping for more finance capital is of course entirely coincidental.]





Since then the position has merely been maintained.  Wherever you take the point in Scotland's history from then on wages are low, profit is extracted from Scotland, and is not reinvested back.  An ossified landed class and an absentee bourgeoisie exerts disproportionate influence over much of the countryside, leading to massive deliberate underdevelopment.  The parties of power at Westminster stand for enforcing a policy uniformity across the United Kingdom which does not correspend with action which would challenge these net capital outflows, fiscal transfers, lower wages or iniquitous distribution of land, patronage and power.  Meantime the military industrial complex of the UK treats Scotland as a dumping ground for nuclear waste, unexploded ordinance, industrial waste and its unpopular nuclear arsenal.  This happens while civil servants in London draw up the plans for UK energy infrastructure which leads to the underdevelopment of our great renewable energy potential.  not content with treating Scotland as a cowp the MoD over-extends its veto powers in the planning system with the same effect on the renewables industry, because the UK refuses to buy a modern radar system, and mere economic necessity is a negative externality.  All of this is in frustration of and for the satrapy government which seeks to end the historical underdevelopment which has characterised long stretches of time in Scotland's interregnum. 

Under Labour Scotland returned billions in unspent Scottish Government finance to the UK Treasury (which we already subsidise to the tune of £1.5billion+ annually).  In 2006 they began a concerted effort to privatise all the public services in Scotland.  Their tenure was associated with the demolition of 1 in 40 homes in the country, all of them publicly owned.  Scotland did not support this kind of government, driven by the City of London and Gordon Brown from London.  Power only exists if it is used and Scotland's emergent break from colonial status to accession as a satrapy begain in 2007 and is an unfinished process.

This potential change in status comes out of the simple fact that this is literally the first time in 150 odd years that Scotland has had a government which intends to do things differently from the right wing / British norm in Scotland.  However normal the SNP's aspirations may be in European terms, that fact alone in Scotland make them revolutionary, because success on their own terms would necessitate ending Scotland's colonial relationship, and exposing the nature of Scotland's ongoing tribute payment relationship with Whitehall.

2.)

The principle agent which can bind Scotland to the Union is Labour.  While Scotland sends its 4% of lawmakers to Westminster under a Labour badge, it votes for the UK Labour Party's policy in Britain, with all the implications for not challenging Scotland's colonial relationship within the Union.

Since the defeat of the working class movement which began in 1979 this has meant enforcing neo-liberalism alongside colonialism's asset transfers.  However the leftwing policies of Labour administrations which predate this arguably relied more on such asset transfers because they faced capital flight and were therefore more reliant on natural resources.  In both incarnations in Scotland - an agent of Thatcherism today, and an agent of command and control Labourism in the fading past - Labour has acted to secure the ongoing asset transfer from Scotland to the Whitehall regime.  Indeed Willie Ross' failed "Socialist Plan for Scotland" was essentially logically predicated within Cabinet on addressing the lower wages, higher unemployment and poorer levels of investment and retention of profits.  And *it failed* when Britain needed the cash for being a big boy instead.

A Labour vote from Scotland is basically a vote for this colonial relationship, particularly when we consider the prize.  And here I completely agree with the Tory Unionist enemy.

The Telegraph's Iain Martin echoes my view. 

" Be in no doubt: if Labour is banished from Scotland, the Union will be done for [... The SNP] hope to hold the balance of power in the event of another hung parliament. That way, they might demand yet more powers for the Scottish Parliament or perhaps even another referendum on ending the Union."

Alex Massie, not normally given to fantastic rhetoric, even believes we have lived thru such a crucible moment that it compares to the Easter Rising in terms of Scottish consciousness.

"Pound for pound – or, rather, per capita – the SNP is now the largest political party in Britain. Indeed, it’s the only one that can plausibly claim to be a mass organisation. That’s quite something.The kind of thing that makes one wonder if – just perhaps – next year’s election in Scotland could produce results of the kind seen in Ireland in 1918. John Redmond’s Home Rule bill was passed in 1914 but its implementation delayed by the First World War. Then there was the small matter of Easter 1916 and, most importantly, the British authorities’ cack-handed response to Pearse’s provocation. It all helped to ruin the Irish Parliamentary Party. They lost 61 seats in 1918 as Sinn Fein won a landslide victory in southern Ireland, gaining 67 seats and winning almost 47 percent of the vote."

If the Labour Party were smashed at Westminster, particularly where this led to a confidence and supply agreement with a minority Labour Government, the political Union would effectively be over, and Scotland would gain full satrapy status by default.  The machinery of the Labour Party in Scotland would be crushed, and the idea that people needed to vote Labour to keep the Tories out would also lie dead.  Paul Sinclair is on record as saying he agrees with this analysis, asking why would people feel the need to vote Labour, if they got a better Labour government by not doing so.  If they got a Tory government, it could only be because England rejected Labour, as the SNP have made clear their intentions never to vote for a Tory Government, in which case all the fairies and unicorns "solidarity" talk during the referendum from the NO campaign would be very very exposed indeed, as would the democratic deficit.  So long as Scotland voted SNP in sufficient numbers this contradiction would be fully and completely exposed and the pressure brought to bear on this reactionary compact of a state.

The eventual outcome of such a shift away from the Labour myth of the post-war welfare state is that Scots see Westminster not as a place which determines their Government, but as a place where they send delegates to fight for Scotland, against Whitehall.  Such a nonsense can only last so long, as the essential colonial relationship would be laid bare for everyone to see.

Given that what British policies mean in Scotland, this is indeed a glittering prize.  It is the result of British policies that in the month of October in Maryhill over 1000 people relied on food parcels to eat. A month previously Maryhill had voted YES by the same size of majority as the landslide among Labour Party members that has swept Jim Murphy into power.  It is the result of British polices that demand is being sucked out of the economy to pay for bloodletting, and economic mismanagement sees vital industries placed on pause amidst a youth unemployment crisis.  Starvation, job losses, economic failure and blight caused by a lack of power to change the welfare system, improve employability and borrow to invest.  None of this is rocket science, but none of it is going to change as long as Scotland is shackled into a relationship where the number of food bank users has equalled the number of SNP members at 2% of the population, the Scottish Government is throwing money hand over fist at alleviating suffering caused deliberately by a distant far right government, while having its budget cut by that same government 7% a year, with no ability to borrow money, all while Scotland subsidises the UK exchequer by an average of £1.5billion+ a year.

3.)

Analysis of Labour's remaining core vote (roughly 50% of its 2010 vote), shows it to be the most suspicious of politicians, the most cynical of elected authority, and together with cynics and fans of Westminster there is a strong majority against the Scottish Parliament gaining political prominence.  A majority of Labour's remaining supporters ticked "neither of them" when asked if they trust Westminster or Holyrood most, and 24% wanted most power invested in Westminster.  Like the number of YES voters in Maryhill this amounts to the same mandate Labour Party members just gave Murphy - only a small minority of Labour's remaining support base wants a stronger Scottish Parliament.  The comparable cohort for the 2010 Labour vote who wanted a stronger Westminster was just 15%, and unlike their remaining support base a majority wanted most power at Holyrood.  Their support is increasingly concentrated among reactionary and erratic political cynics.

This is to say nothing of the actions of those who still command this dwindling and increasingly erratic reactionary support.  Jim Murphy as we know won a landslide victory for reaction among the Labour *membership* vote.  Labour has in the region of 7000 members, up from their pre-referendum total, after they recruited 1000 new members based on one of the most reactionary campaigns in recent Scottish history.  These people want to be led by a bullying, hectoring, creepy right wing lunatic because they see him as the man to crush Scotland's democratic aspirations and put its left wing hopes to bed.  A workers party that's lost its way?  Or a party of colonial reaction and empire fealty?

"Graeme Morrice, Labour MP for Livingston, was
guest speaker at the Bathgate Boyne Celebrations
of East of Scotland Orangemen." Reads the Orange
Lodge campaign website British Together. He went
on to pen an article for "Orange Torch" magazine.
There has been some recent online speculation that Scottish Labour's endorsement of such a right wing creep would "push the SNP to the right"; this is a misreading of history.  The current SNP strategy of being a competent centre left government is the continuation of the party's strategy that it first adopted in the fallout from 1979, where then as now the working class had voted YES but the reactionary upper middle class had voted NO to prevent a change in political weather which might affect their London career ladders and perceived vestiges of patronage.

The idea that Labour is going to push the SNP to the right is a nonsense.  Since 2007, when Labour lost the election after its failed bid to privatise all of Scotland's services, it began a campaign of centre right attacks on the SNP and carping.  From a law and order campaign of moral panic, to Johann Lamont's Cuts Commission, thru to Jim Murphy's wonderful ideas about the need for more pensions firms involved in the financing of public services, the Labour Party has been a force on the right day in and day out.  Now that the combined Unionist candidate now rules expect him to pursue the same strategy as Michael Forsyth did, as #creepyjim tries to prove Scotland is indeed a centre right country.  And the SNP don't.  Like they haven't.  Ever.  At any point in government since 2007.  Or since, as a bunch of left wingers, they came up with their current grand strategy in the 70s and 80s.

Apart from anything else, attack where your enemy is not.  The cold war for Scotland we are living thru is not analogous to the Republicrats versus the Democans where each looks for space in the centre.  That just isn't a fit for what is going on.  The SNP's opposition to austerity for example was not drawn up under similar circumstances to Labour's plan to ban migrants from claiming benefits.  The latter is cynical policy stolen from a poll.  The former is the channelling of political conviction from social democratic instinct, thru a council of economic advisors including some of the world's most celebrated anti-austerity economists, until it becomes a serious and empirically backed policy.

There will be no shift to the right with Labour.  Calling for a vote for Labour is calling for the satrapy to be put back in the box marked colony.

Thursday, 30 October 2014

Is it not time for a full frontal attack at the centre?

The battle is now for the very soul of the country.  It isn't for a loud voice in the margins.  

"the question that the socialist left in Scotland must seek to answer if we are to defend what’s left of our social security system, and present an overall challenge to neoliberalism. This answer is not, it is our contention, with the SNP[...] In a possible future Scotland, Labour and the SNP join in a permanent battle of the civic nationalisms; one British, one Scottish. In this permanent fore-grounding of national antagonisms more vital issues of social justice can be lost[...] This is especially possible should the next leader of Labour in Scotland attack the SNP from the right, in which case the SNP, especially if it believes the left flank is secure, will draw to the centre."

This view strikes me as remarkably similar to John McTernan's reading of politics in Scotland, even tho he's coming from the exact opposite goals.

"The SNP are busy constructing a myth that Scotland is a wildly Left-wing, working-class country. It is not. As the referendum result showed, it is a solidly middle-class, and – dare one say it – moderate Unionist country. “No thanks”, the final slogan of the No campaign, captured that perfectly[...]That was the key to the victories in Scotland of Tony Blair, Donald Dewar and Jack McConnell. And that is precisely where there is vacant ground in Scottish politics – space for a moderate, modern party representing the mainstream middle, that doesn’t blame “London” for all its problems. When your opponent makes a mistake, as the SNP has done, don’t ape it. Exploit it."

I think Shafi is wrong here because I think he fails to appreciate 1) what the SNP represent, 2) what the Labour Party now is, and 3) what Scotland is.

1) The SNP have always proposed a 'Scotland for the smaa fowk.'  This can be dismissed as populism masking nationalism, but this seems like putting theory in place of lived reality.  Yes there have been historical shitty compromises, and yes there have been stupid leaders and political illiteracies.  There is however no getting away from why people join the SNP.  One person in thirty three people in Motherwell is not in the SNP because they are sentimental souls.  It also neglects a generation of history.

Scottish Labour have been attacking the SNP from the right, first in government, and then in opposition for two decades now. In that time the SNP has moved further left.  It has become a mass party of the working class.  This was the vision of the 79 group, more or less. As if to underline that point the current deputy leadership contest has become a debate about the responsibility of the party to the (largely) Jacobin mass movement it has invoked and fostered.

2) On the question of Labour, and organic crises, it ceased to be a Workers Party (in the technical sense of that phrase) at the point when Progress seized the leadership, a generation ago. In form under Blair it was more really a traditional fascist, conservative or Stalinist state style capture of the unions for the ruling elite. At this point it became a party of the Establishment in control *over* the organised working class. The furore over the recent Falkirk selection battle demonstrated conclusively that over two decades on not only was this *still* the case.  That furore happened because Unite had a failed challenge in asserting agency in the relationship, something which remains anathema to the party's rulers.  Because of this 'outrage' Miliband determined it required a change in rules over party funding. The Labour Party remains a Tory Party under Miliband, representing the section of the Establishment which aims to control the unions as the basis of its political power.

This is a direction of travel Blair and Brown were explicit in pursuing.  This ruling class perspective, this course can be summed up in their phrase "the natural party of government" - ie the government that rules forever and ever. The terms of referenence for the policy debate among its rulers, outside of the wee Stalinist-Unionist rump in Scotland, is that of traditional Tory liberalism and Progress' dangerous neo-conservatism.  It is the latter grouping which could be set to trash the last defiant Scottish Stalinist rump, and, in doing so, wipe out the Labour Party in Scotland.


To imagine that Scotland's leading Tory party will force the SNP to the right seems like a misreading of the situation.  That idea that Labour continuing to be Tories, as they obliviate themselves, will force a party that is now a mass movement into a right wing box seems like narrative over logistics.  The SNP is comprised of working class socialists and social democrats.  It's led by a lefty lawyer and machine politician.  We're not going to see some massive rightward shift, because neither the leadership nor the engaged membership are in politics just for the sake of exercising power.  Labour itself counts for much of its vote on centre left low information voter pensioners, but there are diminishing returns in reliance on that demographic. They have long been the tactical Unionist vote, and perhaps the SNP stands to lose some of the centre here if there is a reaction against the explicitly revolutionary component of the mass movement.  This is possible, but that's a circle it has been able to square in the past while leading one of Europe's most centre left administrations.  And frankly Tories know exactly what the SNP is, which is why they have been nervously and perfervidly shuffling and jeering and voting against it since 2007, so appealing for their votes was never going to work.  Labour - the party which stands for government for its own sake - may have to appeal for those votes however.

Is it not time to capture the centre for the smaa fowk and finish the job instead of trying to build a small group of Cassandras?

3) The reason there isn't a need for a Jacobin movement in most countries but there is in Scotland is obvious.  Solutions which elide these relations omit the central question of working class political power in Scotland, which is the Union or democracy.  Now that The British Road To Socialism is as long dead as Clause 4 and the old CPGB and the working class is represented in government by a well turned oot bunch of Jacobins is it not time to just sweep the bastards out?

One third of our land is ruled over by a tax exempt hereditary elite, kept as a desert producing no food, nor profit, nor widespread human use values, locking the remaining poor of our 'interior' into a life of insecurity and poverty, and presenting a barrier to development. We are the only Western country to take a broadly stable government arrangement of roughly one third of our populace and reduce that to a wasteland populated by retirees, with the vestigial working class.  This vestigial working class - still frequently Gaelic speaking by the way - remains in hoc to the gentry and the  new bourgeois rulers who've bought up the massive estates to live out the big house fantasy. 

We are a state of people who control absolutely the very flow of our water, but who do not control whether we let the poor starve.  We pay for this privilege of inertia in the form of tribute and that our finances be doublechecked in England's parliament (where we maintain, under sufferance and sectional alignment a token minority of legislators).  This arrangement is immensely popular with our shrinking violet upper middle classes, who are as privately educated as their Southern peers.  They benefit from obscurity and the crystallisation of class relations we often term 'The Unionist Establishment' or 'Committee Scotland.'

That Ross and others were able to funnel a space for the Labour Establishment into this otherwise private school Edinburgh Tory elite that made its compacts with Henry Dundas 200 odd years ago does not obscure the general principle that Committee Scotland is rarely met but often encountered.

Talking in terms of 'populism' with reference to the SNP is missing the real empirical basis upon which the Pairty o the Smaa Fowk rests, and the necessity of the revolution it represents.  Scotland is a backward country in dire need of land redistribution, changes to property ownership and taxation, democracy and real local government, openness and transparency, a fairer social wage, full employment, Keynesian investment and a political reckoning, all of which the SNP, the mass party of the working class, stands for.